I entered the room when, suddenly...
Past simple sentence
I was with...
Who was with you? What were you doing? Why were you together?
(Now there is a werewolf in the story)
Include a werewolf now or before the next round.
I walked downstairs, because...
Past simple sentence
(Now there are zombies in the story)
Include a zombie or many now or before the next round.
I walked upstairs, because...
Past simple sentence
Suddenly I tripped and fell!...
What did you trip on? Did you fall a long distance? Through a trap door? Where did you end up? Did you hurt yourself?
(Now there are ghosts in the story)
Include a ghost or many now or before the next round.
I was trying to turn on the lights, when...
Past simple sentence
I heard a noise while I ...
I was + Verb -ing
I wanted to call for help, but...
Past simple/continuous sentence
Then, I saw...
What did you see? What happened next?
I found something useful while I...
Past continuous sentence. What were you doing? What did you find and how can it help you?
... was/were following me, so I...
Who was following you? Was it a friend or a foe? What did you do?
I thought something strange was happening because...
Past simple/continuous sentence
... I scared it away with ... but...
What did you scare it away with? How did you do it? What happened next?
The door shut violently behind me and...
Past simple/past continuous sentence
____________ was_____ -ing, but then...
Past simple sentence
(Now there are aliens in the story)
Include an alien or many or a UFO sighting or abduction now or before the next round.
Suddenly, the window opened violently and...
Past simple/past continuous sentence
I felt a hand grabbing me while I ...
Past continuous sentence
I was tiptoeing because...
Who or what could hear you? What happened then?
It was starting to get darker when...
Past simple sentence
I was _________ when something bit me!
What were you doing? What bit you? Did it hurt? What did you do?