Study

Claims & Reasoning

  •   0%
  •  0     0     0

  • Claim: The Giver trusts Jonas. Reason: He shares painful memories with him.
    good
  • Claim: Jonas cares about Gabriel.
    Because he shares warm memories to help Gabriel sleep
  • Claim: Feelings are controlled.
    Because everyone must take daily pills
  • Claim: Lily is rude. Reason: She is only seven years old.
    bad
  • Reason: Because memories change how he thinks.
    Claim: Jonas is growing
  • Reason: Because he breaks small rules.
    Claim: Asher is careless
  • Claim: People lack freedom.
    Because they cannot choose their own jobs
  • Reason: Because he accepts the difficult Receiver role.
    Claim: Jonas is brave
  • Claim: Release is serious. Reason: People do not return afterward.
    good
  • Claim: Fiona is kind. Reason: She helps at the House of the Old.
    good
  • Claim: Family Units are loving. Reason: They are assigned by the Elders.
    bad
  • Reason: Because he sees colors.
    Claim: Jonas is special
  • Reason: Because he helps the newchild Gabriel.
    Claim: Jonas is caring
  • Claim: The rules are strict.
    Because even small mistakes must be corrected
  • Claim: The Giver is weak. Reason: He has gray hair.
    bad
  • Claim: The Elders have power.
    Because they make all decisions for the community
  • Claim: The Giver is important.
    Because he holds all the memories for the whole community
  • Reason: Because he cannot talk about his training.
    Claim: Jonas feels alone
  • Reason: Because he carries painful memories.
    Claim: The Giver suffers
  • Claim: The community hides the truth.
    Because people do not know what release really means
  • Claim: Jonas is special. Reason: He sees colors.
    good
  • Reason: Because they take pills to stop emotions.
    Claim: Feelings are limited
  • Claim: People follow traditions.
    Because the Ceremonies happen every year
  • Claim: The Giver feels tired.
    Because he carries memories alone
  • Claim: Jonas is confused. Reason: He is hungry.
    bad
  • Claim: The rules are unfair. Reason: Jonas does not like to do homework.
    bad
  • Claim: Gabriel needs extra care.
    Because he cannot sleep through the night
  • Claim: Asher is careless. Reason: He often mixes up his words.
    good
  • Reason: Because he learns the truth about release.
    Claim: Jonas feels shocked
  • Claim: People follow rules easily. Reason: They are scared of punishment.
    good
  • Claim: Jonas wants change.
    Because he believes people should feel real emotions
  • Claim: The community is safe. Reason: No one ever feels fear.
    good
  • Claim: The community controls people. Reason: They choose their own clothes.
    bad
  • Reason: Because she speaks her thoughts freely.
    Claim: Lily is honest
  • Reason: Because they cannot choose their job.
    Claim: People lack freedom
  • Claim: Jonas is changing.
    Because he starts to see and feel things he never did before
  • Reason: Because Gabriel cannot sleep well.
    Claim: Gabriel needs help
  • Claim: Jonas is responsible. Reason: He always follows the community rules.
    good
  • Claim: The Receiver job is difficult.
    Because it brings both joy and pain
  • Claim: The Ceremony of Twelve is stressful. Reason: Students only get one gift.
    bad
  • Claim: Jonas is brave. Reason: He faces painful memories.
    good
  • Claim: Memories are powerful. Reason: They can change how you see the world.
    good
  • Claim: Jonas feels shocked.
    Because he learns what release really is
  • Claim: Jonas' father is caring. Reason: He worries about the newchild Gabriel.
    good
  • Reason: Because she works with the Old.
    Claim: Fiona is helpful
  • Reason: Because the Elders decide everything.
    Claim: The community controls people
  • Claim: The apple is important. Reason: It tasted different from normal apples.
    bad
  • Claim: Jonas feels lonely. Reason: He cannot talk about his training.
    good
  • Claim: Jonas feels different from friends.
    Because he sees things they cannot see
  • Reason: Because no one knows real pain.
    Claim: The community hides the truth