Magic Eight Ball or Mr. Potato Head
Magic Eight Ball (1950), Mr. Potato Head (1952)
Silly Putty or Slinky
Slinky (1945), Silly Putty (1949)
Cabbage Patch Kids or Connect Four
Connect Four (1974), Cabbage Patch Kids (1982)
LEGO Bricks or Clue Classic Edition
Clue Classic Edition (1949), LEGO Bricks (1958)
Twister or Yahtzee
Yahtzee (1956), Twister (1966)
Hot Wheels (1967 Ford Mustang Coupe) or Hula Hoop
Hula Hoop (1958), Hot Wheels (1967 Ford Mustang Coupe) (1968)
Tickle Me Elmo or View-Master
View-Master (1939), Tickle Me Elmo (1996)
Spirograph or Tonka Mighty Dump Truck
Tonka Mighty Dump Truck (1965), Spirograph (1966)
Lite-Brite or Operation
Operation (1965), Lite-Brite (1968)
Monopoly or Lincoln Logs
Lincoln Logs (1918), Monopoly (1935)
Wham-O Ultimate Frisbee or Wiffle Ball
Wiffle Ball (1954), Wham-O Ultimate Frisbee (1957)
Ants in the Pants or Beach Ball
Beach Ball (1938), Ants in the Pants (1969)
Duncan Yo-Yo or Eagle Balsa Wood Glider
Eagle Balsa Wood Glider (1926), Duncan Yo-Yo (1932)
Marbles or Crayola Classic Crayons
Marbles (1890s), Crayola Classic Crayons (1903)
Flyboy Pogo Stick or Tinkertoys
Tinkertoys (1914), Flyboy Pogo Stick (1918)
Etch-a-Sketch or Barbie
Barbie (1959), Etch-a-Sketch (1960)
456 Pick Up Sticks or Radio Flyer Wagon
456 Pick Up Sticks (1925), Radio Flyer Wagon (1930)