Study

Indian Act discussion prompts

  •   0%
  •  0     0     0

  • Which card would you argue is the most significant overall for Canadian history, not just Indigenous history?
  • Which card most clearly shows the government’s view of power?
  • Which card shows the most harmful long-term impact? Why?
  • Which card do you think has had lasting intergenerational impacts?
  • Imagine you are a settler in the 1880s: which card would you support most, and why?
  • Which card had the biggest immediate effect on Indigenous communities?
  • Which card shows the clearest example of assimilation? Of control? Of erasure?
  • Which card raises the biggest ethical dilemma for you personally?
  • If you were an Indigenous leader at the time, which card would you resist most strongly?
  • Could any of these cards be justified at the time? Why or why not?
  • Imagine you are a child in a residential school: which card would shape your life most?
  • From the perspective of an Elder today, which card’s impacts are still felt?
  • Which card best shows that the Indian Act was about identity control rather than land or resources?
  • Which card would be the hardest to defend today?
  • If you had to remove one card from the Indian Act, which would it be and why?
  • Rank the top 3 most significant cards — then defend your ranking.
  • From the perspective of a government official, which card would feel “necessary”?