Share Gemara Epic
Save to Folder
Who does his answer NOT make sense according to? Why? *
rav who says its only like a pit if u make it hefkar
What is Rava really saying the Halacha is in the case of the 3 potters? *
he is talking about what they are responsible to pay for? (Their body or property?)
What is his logic/reasoning for saying the second person is Potur when he damages vessels? *
bc he has the same halachas as a pit
Who does his answer make sense according to? Why? *
it make sense according to shmuel who says that every damaging object is looked at as a pit
What's the final answer we give? *
we say that is talking what they are responsible with (body or objects)
What is the case that we are discussing and the halacha rava said
the person fell, the second person tripped and the 3rd tripped.
What question do we ask from the bereisa
the beriesa says that all of them have to only pay for the body and not the property
What do we answer?
The bereisa is not talking about the first person
What is the follow up question we ask?
It says all of them
What does rav ada bar ahava answer?
It means ll the people that tripped behind the first person
What do we ask on this answer?
Who does it say that
How does it make sense according to the Bereisa? As in, how does Rava's answer fit with the wording that says "all of them are potur"? *
we are talking about a case where objects damage other objects
Bonus: Who is ILANS favorite teacher (Hint: NOT Rabbi druin)
Mr. garber
Translate: אֶלָּא אָמַר רָבָא *
rather rabba said
If Danny leaves a bounty target on the floor and David and Ilan come and trip on it who pays for what?
Danny pays for the second one damages and DAVID pays for ilans injuries
Bonus: What would someone have to pay for if their property damages someone else?
hospital bills, Embarrassment, loss of work, pain, damages.
