A man drives 20 km to his in-laws’ house while sleepwalking, kills his mother-in-law, and severely injures his father-in-law. He has a long history of sleepwalking.
Verdict: Not guilty — court accepted that he was sleepwalking and had no criminal intent.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Hot Coffee Case (Liebeck v. McDonald’s, 1992) Facts: An elderly woman spills McDonald’s coffee on her lap, causing 3rd-degree burns. She sues for damages. Question: Was it her fault… or McDonald’s?
Verdict: Mc Donald was guilty. Jury awarded her $2.7 million (later reduced) because coffee was served dangerously hot.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Cat Burglar… Literally (UK, 2013) Police suspect a neighborhood thief is breaking into houses. Turns out it’s a cat bringing home stolen gloves, underwear, and toys from nearby homes. Question: Could the owner be legally liable
Verdict: Not guilty.No charges — cats can’t form criminal intent, and owners weren’t proven to encourage it.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
A woman is murdered. The only “witness” is the victim’s pet parrot, which starts screaming the name of her nephew when police visit. Question: Can an animal’s behavior be used in court?
Verdict: Nephew was arrested and later convicted — the parrot’s behavior led police to investigate him, but the court didn’t treat the parrot as an actual witne
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Trapped Burglar Who Sued (USA, 1982) Facts: A burglar gets stuck in a garage for eight days while the owners are away. Survives on dog food and soda. Sues for mental anguish. Question: Absurd… or legitimate personal injury claim?
Verdict: Not guilty. He won — jury awarded damages.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Dog on Trial (Switzerland, 1990s) Neighbors take a man to court claiming his dog barks nonstop. In court, the dog sits quietly the entire time. Question: Guilty of noise nuisance… or not guilty thanks to perfect behavior in co
Verdict: Not guilty — judge ruled there wasn’t enough evidence the dog barked excessively.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
thief
Give points!
5
10
15
20
25
rocket
Go to first place!
Okay!
gift
Win 10 points!
Okay!
baam
Lose 5 points!
Oops!
15
The Stolen Lifeboat Case (The Mignonette, 1884) Facts: Four shipwreck survivors are stranded at sea. After 20 days without food, two men kill and eat the weakest crew member to survive. Rescued later, they confess. Question: Guilty of murd
Verdict: Guilty — sentenced to death (later reduced to six months in prison).
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
banana
Go to last place!
Oops!
seesaw
Swap points!
Okay!
fairy
Take points!
5
10
15
20
25
baam
Lose 25 points!
Oops!
15
The “Drunk Horse” Case (UK, 2009) Facts: A man is arrested for being drunk in charge of a vehicle. The “vehicle” was his horse. Question: Guilty under traffic laws… or loophole because it’s not a car?
Verdict: Guilty — UK law defines a vehicle broadly, including horse riding on public roads.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Samurai Sword Self-Defense (Canada, 2008) Facts: A man attacked in his apartment grabs a decorative samurai sword and fatally injures the attacker. Question: Excessive force… or self-defense?
Verdict: Not guilty — self-defense was justified.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
boom
Lose 50 points!
Oops!
magnet
Take 5 points!
Okay!
fairy
Take points!
5
10
15
20
25
thief
Give points!
5
10
15
20
25
15
A man breaks into a home, steals electronics, then falls asleep on the couch. The homeowner finds him in the morning and calls police. Question: Burglary and trespass — but could drunkenness be a defense?
Verdict: Guilty — voluntary intoxication didn’t excuse the crime.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Pepsi Harrier Jet (USA, 1996) Facts: Pepsi runs a commercial saying you could win a fighter jet for 7 million Pepsi Points. A man collects enough points and demands his jet. Pepsi refuses.
Verdict: Court ruled for Pepsi — no “reasonable person” would believe a soda promotion included a $33 million jet.
Oops!
Check
Okay!
Check
15
The Great Impostor – Naval Surgeon (1940s–1950s, Canada / Korean War) Case: Ferdinand Waldo Demara, a man with no medical training, impersonated a Canadian naval surgeon and performed multiple surgeries on wounded soldiers aboard navy ship
Verdict: Not Guilty — Although discovered, Demara was not convicted of any crime. The navy quietly dismissed him, acknowledging that his actions saved lives.
