dunk for apples or carve a jack-lantern

have to sleep in a coffin or have to live in a giant pumpkin

meet a vampire or meet a werewolf

have a costume that is really amazing, but also very uncomfortable or have a costume that is not anything all that special, but is comfortable to wear

go to a really great Halloween party where you did not know anyone or go to a kind of lame Halloween party where you knew almost everyone there

be allowed to eat as much Halloween candy as you want for a week, but then have what is left taken away or be allowed to eat only one piece a day but never have it taken away.

dress up as a devil or dress up as an angel

have to wear your Halloween costume to school every day until thanksgiving or have to wear a jack-o-lantern over your head to school for the first three days of November.

have a homemade costume or have a store-bought costume

trick-or-treat in a neighborhood or trick-or-treat at a mall

walk through a graveyard at midnight or spend the night in a spooky, abandoned house

be chased by five zombies or be chased by one werewolf